Truth and Reconciliation

Today Trump has become the first President in US history to be impeached twice. I don’t really understand the system as apparently if the Senate don’t agree he won’t actually face trial – the longer this goes on the more I realise I don’t know the US constitution at all – but either way he’s done for. The Republican Party would have to be mad to nominate him a second time even if he does decide to run in ’24 – but then sanity hasn’t exactly been a key feature of right-wing politics in recent years. Still we can but hope that last week’s riot/insurrection/coup attempt will be a wake-up call for many as to where this is heading.

I’ve been very impressed by what Gary Younge has to say on this topic. Gary is a Guardian journalist and although I’d read some of his articles I didn’t have a very clear idea of what he was like. But yesterday’s interview on the Owen Jones channel was illuminating; Gary is black British and he cut through the debates on Trump, the invasion of the Capitol and the BLM movement in a thoughtful and incisive manner. This is exactly the sort of debate we need right now; considered as well as engaged; not shying away from the difficulties but also refusing to demonise anyone on the other side. And here’s the key to moving forward which, as with everything else, is a difficult balancing act, a fine line to draw. It requires restraint without silence and compassion without collusion.

It’s difficult to end things. The ending of systems of injustice can cause a backlash even worse than the original injustice. Consider the French revolution or the ending of slavery which I mentioned in yesterday’s post about the Melville Monument. CS Lewis knew this too, though he only touches on it; in The Voyage of the Dawn Treader Caspian enforces the end of the slave trade in the Lone Islands after he and his companions are captured and sold as slaves. Afterwards the man he has installed as leader asks him to stay: ‘This ending of the slave trade will make a new world; war with Calormen is what I foresee.’ People do not give up their privileges without a fight, especially if those privileges will undermine the way they make a living. Credit goes to those who foresee this and try to effect some sort of reconciliation, as Mandela did after the ending of apartheid. Without that initiative South Africa would have become a bloodbath; it’s still a pretty violent place but it could have been so much worse. There are some indications that Biden will attempt a similar approach after inauguration, to reach out to former Trump supporters and try to heal divisions. The danger in this is that you weaken your own programme so it’s a difficult line to tread.

In my own small way I’ve been treading that line too on Facebook. As I mentioned before I don’t normally bother debating with people online, but here was a person I know and like in real life who seemed to have been sucked into the cult of Trumpism. So I began to debate with her, to point out that there is no evidence for the election being ‘stolen’ and that some of the so-called ‘news’ outlets she was quoting are not in fact news outlets. I probably got quite vehement at one point and this morning she posted something asking people to debate respectfully so as not to upset others. I have no idea whether that was in reference to my responses though it might have been, so I replied that I hoped my comments had not upset her, but I stopped short of apologising because it seemed to me that to debate this person was the right thing to do. It’s a fine line to tread, to assert your own position without abusing others, and sometimes people do get upset.

So spare a thought for Biden, who may not be the leader we want right now but who has the difficult job of running a deeply divided nation with an ex-president whose followers will stop at nothing to reinstate him. Reconciliation is good – but first comes truth. And before truth comes evidence. So let’s follow that.

Kirk out

4 thoughts on “Truth and Reconciliation

  1. Biden is inheriting an unusual and unprecedented situation in America, and much will be expected of him, right from the start. Not only trying to cope with so much outright hatred, but in the wake of the pandemic too. Whether it is possible to heal the divisions caused by Trump might be a very difficult ask for a rather conservative man who is also quite old. I can see VP Harris having to take over at some stage in the next four years.
    Best wishes, Pete.

  2. No argument whatsoever with what you & Pete have said, Sarada. I can’t wait for John Oliver’s next series to start on PBS [shown on The Comedy Channel on Sky]: he doesn’t hold back one iota in his criticism of the American system, for the benefit of Americans of course, but also to help inform Brits, and he injects his sardonic British humour into his shows which are, for me, hugely enjoyable. Cheers, Jon.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s